The Harbinger Miami Lakes Educational Center Miami Lakes, FL
Issue Date: Saturday, June 01, 2013 Issue: Summer 2013 Last Update: Sunday, June 09, 2013

Blogs

View More

Advertising

At-a-glance

Is virtual education any good?
- Google Images
Advertising

Florida Virtual School is one of many online alternativeschooling options around the country that have become increasingly popular inrecent years. Most high school students will take at least one virtual classduring their four years in school. In Florida, students are now required totake at least one class online before they graduate.

Although virtual school is a useful option for those who donot have time in their schedule to take the class at school, or those whoseclasses are not offered at school but is it really a tool that can replaceeducation in the class rooms?

Most might say it can because it is efficient andinexpensive. However, there is a conflict among students who take these classesabout whether or not they are effectively teaching them.

“Honestly, it’s a lot of information to digest for a courseyou’re taking without the aid of a physical teacher,” Christopher Romero, asenior in Graphic Design said.

There’s a majority of those who feel this way about theironline classes. As opposed to coming into a class three times a week, it ismuch more difficult to remember to go online and work on another class,especially for those students who have busy schedules.

The virtual experience provides many useful resources, liketeacher assistance seven days a week and flexibility with working hours.However, a virtual teacher cannot replace a classroom teacher who can explainmaterial to a student so that it is applicable.

“You learn something, but it’s not enough to make you feelcomfortable with the curriculum in general. Communicating with your teacher isa hassle,” Romero said.

 Learning online ismostly done through reading of lectures which become lengthy and thoroughlyboring. It doesn’t appeal to students who are auditory learners as much as itwould to someone who prefers to simply work on their own.

Other students welcome the idea of virtual schooling.

“I feel like I’m learning more math than I’ve learned atschool and I’m doing so faster and easier,” Eliani Lorenzo, a senior, said.

Although virtual school is much faster than traditionalschool, the average time spent by a student who received an A in the class is18.62 weeks, – according to the Florida TaxWatch. Are students really learning?

It seems that in that amount of time, a student can onlylearn enough to pass the class, but not really retain any information thatmight be useful later on.

Virtual education is rising; an astounding 68% increase instudents from 2006 to 2007. It is becoming more accessible to students and morecost effective for school districts. This is not a replacement for traditionalschooling and should not be seen as one.

“I wholeheartedly prefer daytime school,” Romero added.


Back to the articles list

1 COMMENTS - Add your comment below

8/20/2012 5:07:30 PM by Laura DeSena    
All online education programs are not the same. Those that do not make the distinction between asynchronous online courses (not in real time, like Florida Virtual School) and synchronous courses (live, in real time) are oversimplifying the critical analysis of whether or not online learning is effective. I am a high school English teacher in NJ and I founded an online education program, which synthesized my experience of teaching at NYU as an online instructor of research writing and composition, my experience teaching secondary education and my experience as a homebound instructor. I established an online program to connect students with teachers in the virtual classroom (think webinar) in real time for live instruction -- no delayed responses to questions via emailing students. I am able to connect a homebound student who is out long term due to illness with the content teacher. So the student who cannot attend his Chemistry class is able to connect using Blackboard Collaborate's virtual classroom with his Chemistry teacher and stay current with content instruction and assignments. We also place other students from all over NJ in this classroom together who are out of school due to disciplinary action or illness and so the social element of learning is not compromised even though students are isolated physically at home (homebound instruction). The virtual classroom just like the brick and mortar one allows for full participation in the moment. I am personally tired of the oversimplified review of online learning. I could go on and discuss how discussion board forums and blogging are other forms of interactive, though not in live time, elearning environments but I have given some material for your consideration to embrace some complexity.
ADD YOUR COMMENT
Name
Email
Comments, recommendations or suggestions.
Submit

Staff View

Neyda, Borges

Advisor
Email Me

Iqra

Editor-In-Chief
Email Me

Gaby

Managing/Design Editor
Email Me

Lisabet

Design and Layout Editor
Email Me

Aileen

Senior Business Manager
Email Me

Crystal Serrano

Online Editor/Copy Editor
Email Me

Melissa

Photo Editor
Email Me

Crystal

Photo Editor
Email Me

Sam

Twitter Manager
Email Me

Daniel

Copy Writer
Email Me

Tony

Business Manager
Email Me

Flavia

Copy Writer
Email Me

Karina

Blog Manager
Email Me

Krisna

Business Manager
Email Me

Natalia

Staff Writer
Email Me

Chloe

Staff Writer
Email Me

Jessica

Staff Writer
Email Me

Ruth

Facebook Manager
Email Me

Amanda

Online Co-Editor
Email Me

Julie

Staff Writer
Email Me

Mailei

Staff Writer
Email Me

Carina

Staff Writer
Email Me

Sana

Staff Writer
Email Me

Salwa

Staff Writer
Email Me

Rachel

Staff Writer
Email Me

Alejandra

Staff Writer
Email Me

Michan

Staff Writer
Email Me

Laura

Staff Writer
Email Me

Maria

Staff Writer
Email Me

Lessenit

Staff Writer
Email Me

Vivian

Staff Writer
Email Me

Daniel

Staff Writer
Email Me

Nathalie

Staff Writer
Email Me

Arturo

Staff Writer
Email Me

Ana

Staff Writer
Email Me

View PDF's

Online Archives

There are currently 22 editions on-line. Click on edition name to view articles.

Search