Search
Advertising

At-a-glance

Gallagher Elementary student being patted down by security at school entrance. - Cleveland website
Advertising

As you approach 80 Willoughby St., you may begin to pull out those headphones and store your iPod in your bag. You are greeted with a warm "good morning" or "buenos días niñas" from Mr. Contreras. You head straight to homeroom or might go down to the cafeteria to have some breakfast. What you don’t do is head through a metal detector.

Metal detectors are often used for security measures in an airport, governmental offices or various public schools throughout all five boroughs. According to www.nyclu. org, for about 100,000 public school students in New York City, going through a permanent metal detector is an everyday process. However, according to Catholic Education Resource Center, no Catholic schools are known to have metal detectors in the US, not even in the most dangerous of places.

According to www.nyclu.org, many New York students not only go through the metal detector, but also go through bag searches and pat downs from police officers who are not properly trained. Students and staff often complain of officers being belligerent, aggressive and disrespectful. "The metal detectors often make me late to class and the cops don’t show any mercy," says Shanice Ramsay, a Brooklyn Lab student.

An all-boys Catholic high school in Harlem, known as Rice High School, took in at-risk African- American boys and transformed them into responsible men who gave back to the community. This high school’s alternative to metal detectors was a plaque by the lobby that reads "The Street ‘ENDS’ Here!"

One reason an anonymous student believes we might need metal detectors at SJHS is because the top floors are rented to the GED program. "We don’t know who they are and they have access to our floors, and that’s dangerous," said the student.

After the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks, all schools became required to have a Crisis Management Plan, whether the crisis is a fire, intruders, natural, etc. Principal S. Joan Gallagher reminds us of the time there was a gas leak in the Willoughby Street line last year, which somehow spread into SJHS. At that moment students and faculty had no idea what was going on; all we knew was that we shouldn’t be in the building. Thanks to the Crisis Management Plan, teachers knew what to do and put this plan into action, and carried it out in a calm and orderly fashion.

S. Joan says that as long as she’s principal, metal detectors would never be installed in SJHS because those who visit our building would not feel as if they are trusted. She said a vital part of St. Joseph’s mission is to set up a welcoming atmosphere of hospitality for our guests. "A gracious welcome is one of the most disarming strategies one can engage in," says S. Joan.


Back to the articles list

9 COMMENTS - Add your comment below

3/20/2011 9:47:55 AM by Marcelle    
i like this article and agree with it , it would be safe for the kids and the school .
3/20/2011 9:47:26 AM by Marcelle    
i like this article and agree with it , it would be safe for the kids and the school .
3/18/2011 8:03:42 AM by Nkenge Parris    
I think this article is good because it would be a hassle for students if they had metal detectors. Having no metal detectors says that St. Joseph HS trusts their students.
3/17/2011 11:19:48 AM by Hemala Harilal    
I don't think any catholic school will ever need a metal detector because the quality of protection and safety you get at a catholic school is way better than public schools. I think that this is a last option for schools when they have students who they can't trust.
3/16/2011 6:13:22 PM by Maggioni    
I completely agree with this article. Metal detectors being placed in our school would be the best thing for our own safety!
3/15/2011 8:19:19 PM by Kristie Figueroa    
This was a very great article and I am so glad that st. Joseph is not getting metal detectors because I felt so insecure when I had to go through one at my middle school. I really didn't appreciate people going through my bag, not caring that it was a security guy. My bag has my personal items, its like my journal. Anyways, everything was unorganized and it took a while for all of us to get to our classes. It was a huge waist of time!
3/15/2011 7:10:15 PM by Tasha L    
This was a really good article. It's true metal detectors would be too troublesome. Having no metal detectors shows that there is some kind of trust between S. Joan and us.
3/14/2011 2:38:33 PM by Catherine M    
I think this article is really good because it shows what many students from public schools have to go through just to get in their school. I also like that she added that S. Joan said that as long as she's principal she will not put metal detectors in our school and that makes me feel like she trust us.
3/14/2011 2:38:22 PM by Marianys    
Great article! It deserves to be featured in the National Edition!
ADD YOUR COMMENT
Name
Email
Comments, recommendations or suggestions.
Submit

Staff View

Carmen Mauriello

Advisor
Email Me

Astrid

Editor-in-Chief
Email Me

Heidi

News Editor

View PDF's

Online Archives

There are currently 17 editions on-line. Click on edition name to view articles.

The Parmentier St. Joseph High School Brooklyn, NY
Issue Date: Wednesday, February 06, 2013 Issue: 2012-2013 -- Issue #2 Last Update: Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Current Conditions Mostly Cloudy
Temperature: 67 °F
Wind Speed: 4 mph S
Gusts: 8 mph S
Rain Today: 0 "